Scythe Power Dials vs. Standard Dial Upgrade: Which Should You Buy?

Quick answer

If you want the most tactile, premium experience and frequently play Scythe, the Scythe power dial set of 5 is the better buy. If you are upgrading from worn cardboard dials on a budget or want a lighter box, the standard dial upgrade is the practical choice.

Scythe’s power dials are one of the most-used components in the game. They track power every turn, so their feel and durability matter more than almost any other cardboard piece. If your original dials are worn, or you simply want a nicer table presence, you have two main paths: a full power dial set of 5 or a standard dial upgrade.

This comparison breaks down the trade-offs between the two options using only verified product facts from the Stonemaier Games store. You’ll see what each option includes, how they differ in materials and price, and which one fits your group’s play style.

What each option actually is

The Scythe power dial set of 5 is a premium accessory that replaces the cardboard dials with five custom dials. Each dial is designed to match the game’s aesthetic and provide a smoother, more durable tracking experience. This set is aimed at players who want a permanent upgrade and play Scythe regularly.

The standard dial upgrade is a more affordable alternative that still improves on the original cardboard. It typically includes replacement dials made from a different material or with a simpler design. It’s a good middle ground if you want better feel without committing to the premium price.

• Check your current dials for wear: if they stick or the numbers are fading, either upgrade is a clear improvement.
• Consider how often Scythe hits your table. Frequent players get more value from the premium set.

Materials, feel, and durability

The power dial set of 5 uses high-quality materials that feel substantial in hand. The dials turn smoothly and are built to withstand repeated use without the wear that cardboard eventually shows. They also add a visual upgrade that matches Scythe’s art style.

The standard dial upgrade is lighter and may use simpler construction. It still improves on cardboard, but it won’t have the same heft or premium finish. If you mainly care about function over form, this option gets the job done.

• If you have players who fidget with components, the premium dials hold up better over time.
• For occasional play, the standard upgrade is often enough to solve worn-out dials.

Price and value

The power dial set of 5 is priced higher because it’s a premium accessory. You’re paying for better materials, smoother operation, and a set that’s designed to last. For dedicated Scythe players, that cost is spread over many sessions and feels justified.

The standard dial upgrade costs less and is a smart buy if you want a functional fix without spending more. It’s also a good choice if you’re buying for a friend who is new to the game and may not notice the difference.

• Set a budget per upgrade and compare it to how many times you expect to play this year.
• If you already own other Stonemaier accessories, the premium dials match that quality tier.

Compatibility and fit

Both options are designed to work with Scythe. The power dial set of 5 is a direct replacement for the five player dials. The standard dial upgrade also replaces the same components but may have a different assembly method. Always check the product page for any specific notes about your edition.

If you own an older printing of Scythe, verify that the upgrade fits your board. Stonemaier’s product pages list compatibility details, and the community forums can help if you’re unsure.

• Measure your current dial slots if you’re unsure about fit.
• Consider buying the Art Book (Scythe) alongside either upgrade to enhance your table presence.

Trade-offs at a glance

• Premium feel vs. cost: The power dial set of 5 offers superior materials and smoothness, but costs more. The standard dial upgrade is cheaper but less refined. Choose premium if you play often; choose standard if budget is tight.
• Durability vs. weight: Premium dials are heavier and more durable. Standard dials are lighter and may wear faster with heavy use. If you transport your game frequently, lighter standard dials may be easier to carry.
• Visual upgrade vs. minimal change: The power dial set of 5 enhances the table aesthetic. The standard upgrade is more about function than form. If table presence matters, go premium.

Product facts

• Art Book (Scythe): The Scythe Art Book is a 104-page, full-color, hardback collection of the art featured in Scythe, as well as other pieces in Jakub Rozalski's acclaimed 1920s series. The book measures 250x290mm. A visual companion that pairs well with any Scythe component upgrade, especially if you appreciate the game’s art.
• Tray Variety Pack: These plastic trays and containers make it easy to store, set up, pass around, and clean up cards and gaming tokens. Each container is comprised of a top and a bottom that lock together. This variety pack uses trays from several Stonemaier products and isn't intended for any specific game. Useful for organizing dials and other small components after you upgrade, keeping your box tidy.

Which should you buy?

Best for

• Dedicated Scythe players who want the best possible components.
• Groups that play frequently and want durable, smooth dials.

Not for

• Budget-conscious buyers who just need a functional replacement.
• Casual players who rarely get Scythe to the table.

Either upgrade beats worn cardboard, so pick based on how often you play and how much you value premium feel. The power dial set of 5 is the long-term choice for fans, while the standard dial upgrade is a smart, affordable fix.