54 Metal Doubloon Coins (Libertalia)

These coins have real heft—noticeably thicker than the cardboard originals, and the copper and silver tones look great on the table. They stack neatly and feel like actual treasure.

I swapped out the flimsy cardboard coins for these and the table presence is night and day. The 24 copper $1s and 18 silvers have a nice heft and the denominations are easy to read across the board. Stacking them feels great too.

The copper $1 coins have a satisfying clink when you stack them, and the silver pieces feel weighty enough that you actually want to handle them during payouts. Way better than the cardboard chits that came in the box.